I really got her attention when I told her, “I'd rather eat a pussy than fuck it, especially yours.” She said both she and her husband had enjoyed receiving oral sex in their previous marriages and had tried it on each other on their honeymoon, but neither of them liked to give it. Mary loved the idea of my eating her pussy, but asked me if she let me do it, if I wouldn't mind not being paid back with a blowjob. I assured her I didn't need her to suck me as long as she didn't mind me having a good wank once she was satisfied. “Wow,” she said. “I think we're gong to be really good neighbors from now on.” Then once again, she wanted to make sure I didn't mind her pussy being full of cum. I bravely told her it wouldn't bother me in the least. She said a man slurping up another man's cum from a woman's cunt was called eating a ‘cream pie.' I had never heard the term before and just laughed. She said if I was ready she was ready.

She spread a large towel out on the bed and then pulled off her big T-shirt revealing her great looking boobs pointing right at me and her pussy just covered in a snug pair of lime green panties. She explained the panties held her panty liner tightly against her pussy to keep the man slime from leaking out because she loved the feeling of it sloshing around inside her. Seeing her panties suddenly reminded me of the pair of my pink nylon panties I had on at the very moment under my sweatpants. I didn't know how she would react if she saw them, and I didn't want to blow this whole gig, so I was determined to try to keep her from seeing them.

I took off my T-shirt. She climbed on the bed and I climbed on after her, positioning myself between her legs and stared at her sweet panties as she reached down inside them and pried the panty shield away from the crotch of her panties. Then she eased the crotch piece of her pale green panties aside but continued to hold the shield in place against her cunny.

Mary grabbed my hair and said “I hope you're ready for this,” as she removed the panty shield from her cunt and immediately shoved her pussy up against my open mouth. Cum -- thick, white cum oozed from her pussy, and I was lapping it up. Mary must have seen the surprised look on my face at the volume of cum and then admitted she had been fucked eight times in the last two hours, twice each by Tom and his three friends. She didn't want to tell me that earlier for fear I wouldn't want to suck such a sloppy pussy since she had gotten so turned-on by our conversation that she couldn't face not having her pussy eaten as soon as possible.

I was a little overwhelmed by the amount of cum and had to swallow quickly to avoid choking. The salty taste wasn't bad, a mixture of sweet and bitter flavors, obviously reflecting the differences in the four men who had fucked her. The texture varied from thin to thick, and the continued flow was proof she had been fucked one hell of a lot! She asked me how I liked eating her big cream pie, and since my mouth was full, I could only nod a little show her with my eyes that I was delighted.
“I thought you wanted to jerk off while you ate me,” she said.

I told her I would love to, but with her sitting on my chest, my arms were a little constricted and it was difficult for me to manipulate myself. That's when she reached behind herself and, without looking, shoved her one hand down inside the stretchy waistband of my sweatpants and instantly took hold of my cock through my nylon panties.

“My those are sleek under shorts you have on. Are they silk?”

“No, nylon,” I admitted, hoping that would end her curiosity and prevent her from turning around to take a look!
 
Now as she rode my face, she jerked on my dick. She smiled down at me and said I guess I can figure out why you are a pussy eater, your penis is pretty small, oh, I'm sorry, I mean kind of average, if you don't mind me saying.”

I could feel tears in my eyes. I really didn't want to appear anything less than a real man for her, especially at this moment as she was thrilling me by jacking on my prick in my panties.

Between her pulling on my pantied dick and me sucking and eating her cunt, I was in heaven. She didn't stop jerking on me but stopped wiggling her hips on my face as she paused for a moment and said, “So, for how long have you been wearing women's panties?”

With a mouthful of pussy I could only groan and look up at her with pleading, sorrowful eyes.

“Don't worry. I think it's cute you wear panties. I guess you have to do something to entertain this little guy of yours since your wife isn't interested in having sex with you. And panties on you make sense since I don't suppose you're too anxious to show girls what little you have down there; after all, a girl usually wants to see what you have before she lets you fuck her.”